A VSOP gives employees a contractual right to a cash payment equal to the value of a number of shares at an exit. It needs no notary and no real shares, but the payout is taxed as employment income. Real share options (ESOP) give actual ownership but need notarisation and can create tax before any cash arrives. German rules (§19a EStG) have improved real-share options.
- VSOP: cash payment at exit mirroring share value; no voting rights; no notary per grant.
- VSOP payouts are generally taxed as salary, with social contributions.
- ESOP with real GmbH shares requires notarisation and can trigger tax on grant ("dry income").
- §19a EStG, expanded from 2024, allows deferral of tax on employee shares in qualifying companies.
- Delaware parents can use US-style option plans, with local tax advice for German employees.
Why is real equity hard in a GmbH?
Every new GmbH shareholder requires a notarised transfer or capital increase. Giving shares to ten employees means ten notarial acts and ten new names in the commercial register. Shareholders also gain statutory rights, such as information and attendance rights, that founders may not want to give to every employee. Hence the virtual alternative.
How do VSOP and ESOP compare?
| VSOP (virtual) | ESOP (real shares/options) | |
|---|---|---|
| What the employee gets | Contractual cash claim tied to exit value | Actual shares or options on shares |
| Notary | No | Yes, for share transfers or issues |
| Shareholder rights | None | Yes |
| Tax timing | At payout, as employment income | Potentially at grant or vesting; deferral possible under §19a EStG if conditions met |
| Tax rate on gain | Income tax rates | Can be capital gains treatment on later appreciation |
| Admin | Simple | Heavier |
What changed with §19a EStG?
Germany expanded the tax deferral for employee shares from 2024 through the Future Financing Act (Zukunftsfinanzierungsgesetz). In qualifying smaller and younger companies, tax on shares received by employees can be deferred rather than due at grant. The conditions are detailed, so check them with a tax adviser before choosing a plan.
What should a good plan include?
- A vesting schedule, typically four years with a one-year cliff.
- Clear good and bad leaver rules.
- What counts as an "exit" that triggers payment.
- How the value per virtual share is calculated, including liquidation preferences.
- Plain-language explanation for employees.
Size the plan with the option pool shuffle in mind, and see how much equity to give first employees. Founder equity follows different rules: founder vesting in Germany.
How is a VSOP payout calculated?
An illustrative example. An employee holds 1,000 virtual units with a base value of €10 per unit. The company is sold at a price equal to €110 per share after liquidation preferences.
| Step | Amount |
|---|---|
| Exit value per unit | €110 |
| Minus base value | €10 |
| Payout per unit | €100 |
| Gross payout (1,000 units, fully vested) | €100,000 |
| Taxed as | Employment income in the year of payment |
Many plans pay out only on an exit, not on a later financing round, and some let the company or the acquirer settle in shares instead of cash. Read the plan's definition of "exit" carefully.
What do employees often misunderstand?
- That virtual units are not shares and carry no vote.
- That the payout comes after investors' preferences.
- That leaving the company may forfeit unvested, and sometimes vested, units.
- That tax is due at payout, as salary, not at a lower capital-gains rate.
When does a real-share plan make more sense?
For senior early hires who expect to be long-term owners, for companies that qualify for deferral under §19a EStG, or where a US parent already runs a US option plan. Some German startups combine both: real shares for a few key people, virtual units for everyone else. Size either plan with how much equity to give first employees.
Frequently asked questions
What is a VSOP?
A virtual stock option plan: employees receive a contractual right to a cash payment equal to the value of a set number of shares when the company is sold or listed.
How is a VSOP taxed in Germany?
The payout is generally taxed as employment income when received, with social security contributions.
Can German startups give real shares to employees?
Yes, but each share transfer needs notarisation, and tax may arise early. The 2024 changes to §19a EStG allow deferral in qualifying cases.
Do VSOP holders have voting rights?
No. They are contractual creditors of a future payment, not shareholders.
Let investors find what you're building.
OBridge is an early-access discovery network for founders and investors. Post your build, share your progress, and let verified investors mark you Investable — a private, no-amount signal of interest, not an offer or a commitment.
Join the waitlist →Sources and further reading. §19a EStG; Index Ventures, Rewarding Talent.
Educational material, not legal, tax or investment advice. Rules and figures change; confirm with qualified counsel or a tax adviser in your jurisdiction before acting. Last updated October 6, 2026.